Where Do Broken Hearts Go (Sequel to You and I)

Connie's POV

"I love you, Evan." She said.

"I love you too, Emily." Evan said.

Evan kissed her on the forehead until all of a sudden, he looks towards my directions.

His eyes were opened really wide.

So was mine. My eyes were tearing and I felt this pain in stomach that I've never felt before.

"Oh my gosh, Connie I-" Evan said.

Before he could finish his sentence, I dropped all of his stuff and I ran down the stairs. My eyes were a bit blurry from all the tears as he followed me. I made it to the front of his house, when someone grabbed my arm.

"Connie! Stop! Listen to me!" Evan said as he tried to not let go of me.

I looked at him and said, "How could you do this to me..."

"Connie, I'm sorry, I-" Evan tried to explain.

"You knew how I felt about you even back when we were friends. I gave us a chance because I thought I knew you. I thought I knew you as someone who is genuine, kind-hearted and someone who is truthworthy. All of those things that you told me about having feelings for me and being in love with me, were they not true?" I asked.

"Of course they were! I-" Evan said.

"Please leave me alone... I don't want to talk to you right now." I said as I pulled away slowly.

Evan slowly released his hand from my arm.

I turned the other direction and headed towards my car. I hopped into my car and drove away. While I was driving, I could still feel the tears running down my face. I had to park my car into a nearby neighborhood because I couldn't drive anymore. My head was on the steering wheel as more tears started to form.

Bernice's POV

I was getting ready for the boys and girls to come over when all of a sudden, I hear the doorbell ring. I walked towards the door and saw all of them at the front of my doorstep.

"Hey guys! Come in!" I said as I hugged each of them.

"Now we can get this party started!" Louis said as he started running around my house.

I started to laugh but we all headed towards my living room. We were all talking and laughing when I realized Niall was very quiet. He was just sitting on the sofa by himself. I walked towards him and sat down next to him.

"Hey Niall, you alright? You've been so quiet." I said.

"I'm fine, I guess." Niall said.

"Well, you don't look fine. What's up?" I asked.

"I don't know, I guess I kind of realized I made a huge mistake. A year ago when I broke it off with Connie, I can never forget the sad expression on her face. She seemed so hurt and betrayed because I promised her that no matter what happens, I'll be there for her and everything will be okay. And look how thing turned out now." I said as I ran my fingers through my hair.

I placed my hand on his back to comfort him. All of a sudden, my phone started to ring.

Niall's POV

Bernice placed her hand on my back to try to comfort me. All of a sudden, her phone started to ring.

"Hello?" She said. She started to look concerned.

"What?! What happened?" She said on the phone, loudly.

I wonder what was happening.

"Where are you right now? I'll come see you as soon as I can." I said. I hung up the phone.

"What happened?" I said as I looked concerned.

"Um..." Bernice said as she hesitated.

I kept on looking at her until she finally told me.

"Connie caught Evan cheating on her with another girl." Bernice said.

At that moment, I could feel this kind of anger starting to built inside of me. My face was turning red as I was about to explode. I clenched my fist as hard as I could looking like I was going to punch someone. I quickly got up and headed to the door.

"Where are you going Niall?" Bernice asked.

"To talk to Evan." I said as I left the house and drove off.

When I got to his home, I went to the door and rang his doorbell. Surprise, surprise, Evan was the one who opened it. I didn't take a second thought and I punched him as hard as I could right in the face. He fell over.

"Dude, what the heck?!" He said.

I picked him up and slammed him against the wall.

"How could you do that to Connie? She really liked you. Don't ever come near her or even talk to her ever again, you hear me?!" I shouted.

I let him go and walked back to my car and drove away. I used my phone and called Bernice.

"Hello?" Bernice said.

"Bernice, where's Connie right now?" I said.

"She's at her house. I was just about to go over." She said.

"No worries, I'm going over there right now. Is it alright if I talk to her?" I asked.

"Sure, no problem." She said.

We hung up the phone. When I got to Connie's house, I rang her doorbell. Connie opened the door and she still had tears in her eyes. I leaned in to give her a hug. She hugged me back because she probably knew that I knew what had happened.

"Evan's such a jerk. You don't deserve someone like him. He's not even worth forgiving." I said.

We were still hugging. When we let go, I asked her, "Can I come in?"

She nodded her head and she closed the door behind me. We both sat on the couch and talked about this whole thing. She finally calmed down a bit and was able to speak.

"I just never thought he would do this to me. I thought he had feelings for me." She said while she was looking down.

"How about we go get some dinner and get your mind off of things?" I asked.

We both got up and headed towards my car. We stopped by a local pizza place around her neighborhood.

"Order anything you want." I said.

She laughed a bit. "It's fine. I'll just pay for it myself."

Connie was heading towards the cashier and ordered her food. When she was just about to pay, I went right in front of her.

"Hello, can I order one of everything that you have on this menu?" I asked.

Connie's eyes were wide opened, even the cashier.

"Um, what are you doing? That's a lot of food." She said.

"Well, we both eat a lot, so why not right?" I said as I turned to her.

"Yes, but that costs a lot." She said.

"Don't worry about the money." He said.

Connie's POV

Did he literally just order everything on the menu for two people?! Leave it to Niall for doing the most craziest things. They brought the food to our table a bit by bit and we just started eating.

Niall was telling my all the funny stories that had happened on tour. It made me laugh so much that my stomach started hurting. Hanging out with Niall really took my mind off of what had happened today because we were enjoying our food and laughing a lot. It was a great time.

After we had finally finished, we decided to go to a small park near the pizza place. It was around seven at night and the sun was setting.

We didn't feel like doing much cause we were so full, so we just watched the sunset while sitting on the grass.

"This is nice." Niall said.

"It is." I said.

We kept on looking at the sunset for a bit.

"Hey Niall, can I ask you a question?" I said.

"Sure." He said.

"Do you think I'm not good enough for anyone?" I asked.

Niall's POV

"Hey Niall, can I ask you a question?" She said.

"Sure." I said.

"Do you think I'm not good enough for anyone?" She asked.

I was pretty shocked. I can't believe she just asked me that. I turned my head slowly and held her hand.

"Connie, I think you're the most amazing, loving, selfless, thoughtful, and kindest person I've ever met. Evan is the one that's not good enough for anyone." I said.

She looked at me and our eyes met. She smiled at me. She leaned in and kissed my cheek.

"Thanks Niall." I said.

"Come on, I'll take you home." He said.

We both got into his car and drove away. When he got back to my house, I asked if he wanted to hang around for a bit.

We went up to my room and no, it's not what it sounds like. We just sat on my desk and watched a horror movie together. Connie seemed tired, because she couldn't keep her eyes opened for most of the movie.

She was very tired that I didn't notice that she fell asleep. I carried her onto her bed. I was just pacing around her room. I was looking at her baby photos and I started smiling. They were adorable. I kept looking around her room and I saw something sticking out of her jewelry box.

I walked up to it and opened it. There, I found the necklace that I had given her. I really thought she threw it away after we had broken up a year ago. I was just examining the necklace, when all of a sudden, I heard Connie screaming.

"No, stop Evan! Niall? Niall?" She said in her sleep and she kept on moving around.

I approached her bed and tried to calm her down.

"Connie, wake up! It's just a dream." I said.

Connie finally woke up.

"Oh, I'm sorry. I think you realized that sometimes I still get nightmares." She said.

"They haven't stopped for you?" I asked.

"Nope." She said.

I was just about to continue the conversation when I heard the door open from downstairs. It seemed like her parents and her sister was home.

"I think I'm going to go now. Get some rest." I said as I kissed her forehead. She went straight back to sleep. I guess she was really tired.

I headed downstairs and I saw Connie's parents and sister.

"Well, Niall! It's such a surprise! I didn't expect you to be here! Come give us a hug." Her mom said.

I gave each of them a hug.

"How are you?" My sister, Crystal said.

"It's been great. Tour's been great. We had a concert in Toronto and we're on break now, so we thought we would visit Bernice and Connie." I said.

"That's wonderful! But it's getting late now. Are you going home now?" Her mom asked.

"Yeah, I was just about to say goodbye and leave because Connie fell asleep." I said.

"Well, hope you have a good night and it was nice seeing you." Her mom said.

"You too." I said as I smiled.

I waved goodbye to everyone. I was just about to leave when someone placed their hand on my shoulder.

"You know Niall, when Connie was sleeping, did she have any nightmares and started calling your name." Crystal asked.

"Yeah, she did. I woke her up to comfort her." I said.

"It seems to me it has gotten worse over the year and she always calls your name for help in her nightmares." Crystal smiled said as she tapped me on the back.

I turned around and left the house. I went into my car and took a deep sigh as I drove away to pick up the boys.

Notes