Luke:
You guys would be sitting on the steps eating pumpkin pie and comparing big orange-brown leaves you found in the yard and he’d see that your nose was turning pink because it was chilly outside and he’d pull his sweater off from the back like boys do and tell you to lift your arms so he could put it on you and then he’d pull you into his lap and feed you a forkful of the pie and you’d both be blushy

Ashton:
You two would be at the park and it’d be really window so you stole his scarf and he’d be chasing you around to get it and he’d tackle you and you’d hear all the leaves and grass crunch beneath you and he’d ask what you want to be for Halloween and you’d tell him you don’t know yet and he’d say something corny like “my girlfriend” and then he’d lean down and kiss you and even though both of your lips are slightly chapped from the cold neither of you mind

Calum:
You would be carving pumpkins at the kitchen table and since it’s nice outside all of the windows would be open but when the wind blows you get a cold chill and he sees you shiver real quick so he’d move away from his pumpkin and stand behind you, gently pressing you between the table and him and he’d wrap you in his arms and put his heat on your shoulder and warm you up

Michael:
You’d be having a scary movie marathon on Halloween and he’d jump every time trick-or-treaters knocked on the door and he’d pause the movie and let you give them candy and when you got back he wouldn’t let you sit back down because he spread out on the couch so you lay across him and he changes the station to It’s The Great Pumpkin Charlie Brown and you’d finish all the candy so you couldn’t answer the door when anymore kids came

Notes